Join The Fat Kid Club
Receive exclusive updates and special offers on your favorite stuff.
Classic ‘80s Donnie Baseball—clean cut, laser-focused, and still rocking the best mustache in the league. This 1989 Fleer #258 captures Mattingly in his prime. PSA 10 means it’s perfect—sharp edges, flawless gloss, and zero gum stains.
A pure Yankee icon in cardboard form, locked in gem mint forever.
Packed and shipped fresh from Fat Kid’s parents’ basement, where the Fat Kid is known as Donnie Donuts.