Join The Fat Kid Club
Receive exclusive updates and special offers on your favorite stuff.
The mustache. The stance. The birth of “Donnie Baseball.” This 1984 Topps #8 Rookie Card is pure Yankees royalty—Mattingly before the MVPs, the sweet swing before the back gave out. PSA 9 means it’s near-perfect, sharp corners, and nostalgia so thick you can smell the bubble gum.
A cornerstone of any 80s baseball collection, this is the card that turned Don Mattingly into a Bronx legend—and display cases into an altar of pre-roid baseball.
Packed and shipped fresh from Fat Kid’s parents’ basement, where our big apples are usually candy coated.